Krs71 wrote: I think most of managers are honest about their players' talent. I only met one who lied about players' talent and I would never buy a player for him. Even if he is 5 stars talent and only 1 000. Just for my rules That's how we should do against those bastards Don't buy their players and that's a good punishment.

Amen!

I'm absolutely honest in my ads too.
I did not start this thread to encourage to lying, but to give the warning to all managers that ADs can not be trusted.

false advertising is a no no in the big world so why should it be acceptable from managers in this game. if you dont trust the person then scout, not that you should have to take that approach but the safest option.

nothing wrong with naming and shaming the false advertisers like any other business who does this profits should fall from the claims.

pstimpel wrote: This is an absolute NO GO for the public list! It is not on the community to judge, that is admins job.

Then why would you judge by saying "there's no go.." ?

MasterMark wrote: pstimpel wrote: This is an absolute NO GO for the public list! It is not on the community to judge, that is admins job. Then why would you judge by saying "there's no go.." ?

Because I don't judge, and you should not do too!

Blacklisting is always the worst way to solve such problems. Is it that hard to understand? Who decides if an user gets blacklisted or not? What are the criteria for or against? Who unlists a manager? Why? Who can guarantee that only users are on blacklist that should be there?

Dont understand me wrong: of course I am against lying or cheating. But blacklisting is a dumb solution, and we need smart ones to solve problems like this.

You agree?