So, I am trying this game out to see if it is something i would like to spend time playing, but there are a few problems that I have recognized from reading the forums, playing a game, etc.

1. Older members argue that there isn't enough of a tactical element in the game

yes, once you get into the game the restrictions on how to play the game effectively are a little frustrating. It's all about a passing attack.
2. The game seems to be focused on player development and moving up through the divisions
in fairness this is going to be the case for all management games and is a feature/ style that i like (personally)
3. You can apparently only select one possible formation for each side of the ball through an entire game, regardless of down and distance
yup
4. The supporter account seems a little expensive for the benefits it offers
ignoring all the fluff, training reports and access to skill details and caps is very useful
5. You can't really tell the sim engine to highlight a specific player for passes or runs
you can indiectly, play one receiver / RB on a particular side and select preference for that side in match orders

and here are a few good things I have noticed

1. Lots of opportunities for playing a game (match)
yep, at least two matches a week, plus potential for several more in cup and aflc (in a few seasons)
2. The movement through the divisions seems fun, at least until you reach the upper ranges, at which point advancement might not occur again
seeking promotion is the aim of the game, it stays fun at the top trying to hold onto the top spots and pushing to go for the iron bowl
3. The slow pace of development might be able to prolong interest until one has a quality team
hmm..
4. The community seems chatty, helpful, and friendly
best part of the game by a long way, the active and fun community i think i prob responsible for keeping about 30% of the veteran players


so, is that a pretty accurate appraisal?
what do you veterans think?