I have two offensive lineman with the stats below
that have played nearly a full season now in position.

I am mystified though, how player two can consistently be rated much better than player one when, on paper, one should be much better than two ?

- Player One - Player Two

Position - 1 - 7
Vision - 5 - 1
Intelligence - 20 - 19
Footwork - 6 - 3
Carrying - 2 - 7
Tackling - 2 - 3
Blocking - 7 - 6
Passing - 2 - 4
Catching - 4 - 2
Kicking - 1 - 2
Punting - 3 - 4
Speed - 11 - 13
Strength - 11 - 13
Agility - 7 - 2
Stamina - 6 - 1

Average rating on
match day stars - 1 to 1.5 - 2 to 2.5

I would love to hear what more experienced players make of this.

Would be more relevant in the player evaluations/advice thread above, but nevermind

Talent, also.

Chemistry and teamwork are close, but player 2 has a HUGE advantage in consistency and most likely at least a full star(probably more) advantage in BPOS.

Be patient and keep playing player 1 at OL and his BPOS will continue to increase. At that time his game rating should raise.

Yeah, straight up, it's the BPOS rating that's hurting the first player. Keep playing him though, and he'll be just fine.

Edit: I just checked out your gunner, if it's the 28 year old, the problem is his energy. Which I didn't even consider when I looked at your OL. 79% energy is what's killing him..

Roll on the training update promised that will allow us to rest an individual player. Is there no other way of getting that energy level back up again ?