I have 2 QBs and I'm curious to everyone's opinion on which one would play better and be more effective



Daniel Blocken (ID 1333003)
The Winners (Canada)
20 year old Quarterback
1.5* rating
2* talent

SKILLS
Positioning 1 Tackling 2 Punting 3
Vision 5 Blocking 4 Speed 13
Intelligence 18 Passing 12 Strength 10
Footwork 3 Catching 6 Agility 3
Carrying 2 Kicking 2 Stamina 5

WEIGHT & HEIGHT
Weight (lb) 152 Height (ft) 6'1" BMI 20.1

OTHER
Teamwork 4 Consistency 20

OR


Marco Neubert (ID 1308694)
The Winners (Canada)
19 year old Quarterback

Rating 3.5*
Talent 4*
SKILLS
Positioning 4 Tackling 2 Punting 5
Vision 5 Blocking 5 Speed 13
Intelligence 8 Passing 8 Strength 9
Footwork 4 Catching 4 Agility 3
Carrying 4 Kicking 1 Stamina 3

WEIGHT & HEIGHT
Weight (lb) 187 Height (ft) 6'2" BMI 24.0

OTHER
Teamwork 18 Consistency 8

I know for the long term Neubert would be the better option (higher talent, BPOS, and easier to train) but right at this moment, which QB would you rather have starting for you?

At this stage, your current starting QB is an afterthought. With a mostly bot league, you need a decent RB, and he doesn't even need to be expensive. Just high BPOS will be enough. All other positions, you need to be building towards the long term future. Find players speed and strength caps and with intelligence and consistency, place high talent players where they will fit best and keep playing them there. Eventually, you'll start training the appropriate skills for the positions. The truth is that a passing skill difference between 1 and 6 for instance doesn't really mean anything. Personally, I consider a player untrained until he has a non-fitness skill of @10 or higher.

Actually I just picked up this player yesterday, would he be my #1 option instead?



Jorge Pereira (ID 1392549)
The Winners (Canada)
18 year old Tight End


Rating 1* QB
Talent 3.5*

SKILLS
Positioning 1 Tackling 1 Punting 2
Vision 2 Blocking 1 Speed 11
Intelligence 20 Passing 4 Strength 7
Footwork 4 Catching 6 Agility 2
Carrying 4 Kicking 3 Stamina 4

WEIGHT & HEIGHT
Weight (lb) 255 Height (ft) 6'4" BMI 31.0

OTHER
Teamwork 19 Consistency 12