Just to be more precise, here's his entire stats...

Positioning 3 Tackling 4 Punting 1
Vision 4 Blocking 3 Speed 8
Intelligence 15 Passing 3 Strength 13
Footwork 4 Catching 2 Agility 1
Carrying 5 Kicking 2 Stamina 2


Weight (lb) 227
Height (ft) 6'1"
BMI 29.9

Teamwork 3
Consistency 3
Weeks at club 10

It is unlikely, given that you're a division 5 team with limited resources, that he will get to 19/20 in a stat such as tackling, which means inconsistency is not necessarily to his detriment. There are also certain positions where a less consistent persona could be advantageous, such as kick returning or in the defensive line.

Lack of consistency is a big handicap in the transfer market currently, and can reduce a player's value to a quarter of what it might otherwise be, but this does not mean that such a player is useless, or even undesirable, if you play him in the right positions.

In short, train him where his physical attributes suit him best and enjoy his performances and improvement.