Grid-Iron american football game language selector
Language
ČeštinaDanskDeutsch
EnglishEspañolEspañol (Latinoamérica)
FrançaisItalianoMagyar
NederlandsPolskiPortuguês (Brasil)
RomânăSlovenčinaSlovenščina
SrpskiSuomiБългарски
РусскийУкраїнська 
Register
Login
Player Evaluations and Advice.
Forum index >> Center for rookies >> Player Evaluations and Advice. Goto page : 1, 2, 3 ... 66, 67, 68 ... 75, 76, 77
 
mdjseymour
Posts: 0
Posted on 2009-10-09 13:15:39
darkwingaa wrote:


First Player: Talent 4

Positioning 3 Tackling 7 Punting 3
Vision 6 Blocking 7 Speed 12
Intelligence 16 Passing 4 Strength 14
Footwork 3 Catching 1 Agility 1
Carrying 3 Kicking 7 Stamina 2

Teamwork 7 Consistency 20



Hmmm nice strength ans speed, good intelligence, good vision and good tackling... (also good blocking) i would be tempted to say MLB, depending on how his speed and strength develop, or possibly FB, but think it might be a waste there... could even think about Strong Safety, again depends on how his speed and strength increase, but 4 talent and superb consistency are a winner for him... (want to sell? lol)

darkwingaa wrote:


Second Player Talent 4

Positioning 7 Tackling 2 Punting 3
Vision 2 Blocking 3 Speed 15
Intelligence 6 Passing 7 Strength 11
Footwork 7 Catching 5 Agility 5
Carrying 3 Kicking 6 Stamina 3

Teamwork 11 Consistency 15



Another nice talented guy... low(ish) intelligence, speed is nice, footwork, agility, i would be tempted to say RB, even though his carrying needs work... others may say Safety, etc but i like a little more intelligence in those positions...

darkwingaa wrote:


Third Player Talent 3

Positioning 1 Tackling 7 Punting 7
Vision 2 Blocking 7 Speed 10
Intelligence 17 Passing 7 Strength 8
Footwork 6 Catching 7 Agility 5
Carrying 7 Kicking 2 Stamina 4

Teamwork 3 Consistency 13



Mediocre talent, mediocre speed and strength, mediocre consistenct, good inteligence... punting in 7, but kicking is only 2, carrying, catching, tacking, all decent... i would be tempted to play them as a Punter - reason - while they have the skills for other positions, the strength and speed are low. Alternatively bench them, train up speed and strength and see where they cap...

with 3 star talent, remember, he will only get up to 4 star BPOS, so may be a backup in the future...
viktor
Posts: 0
Posted on 2009-10-12 22:51:18
Would u keep this player? And will he make it to the first team? And at what position?

Rating 1.5
Talent 4.5
SKILLS
Positioning 5 Tackling 3 Punting 4
Vision 2 Blocking 1 Speed 12
Intelligence 1 Passing 1 Strength 12
Footwork 4 Catching 4 Agility 4
Carrying 4 Kicking 1 Stamina 1

OTHER
Teamwork 2 Consistency 1

buckeye1022
Posts: 8799
Posted on 2009-10-12 22:54:36
While the talent is great, I probably wouldn't keep him because of the low teamwork, consistency, AND intelligence.
mdjseymour
Posts: 0
Posted on 2009-10-12 22:55:46
viktor wrote:

Would u keep this player? And will he make it to the first team? And at what position?

Rating 1.5
Talent 4.5
SKILLS
Positioning 5 Tackling 3 Punting 4
Vision 2 Blocking 1 Speed 12
Intelligence 1 Passing 1 Strength 12
Footwork 4 Catching 4 Agility 4
Carrying 4 Kicking 1 Stamina 1

OTHER
Teamwork 2 Consistency 1



personally i would think of getting rid of him, if they have Consistency very low, but talent high, im tempted to keep them, but combined with that terrible intelligence ans team work... i would only be happy playing him at DT or OL... and even then only if he had Superb Strength and high consistency.... something he does not have... but im sure someone would give you cash for him...

may be worth training up speed and strength a little and then sellnig him, or deciding if you want to keep him...

you could keep him to play gunner or KR possibly, depending on how his speed goes....
mdjseymour
Posts: 0
Posted on 2009-10-12 22:56:57
buckeye1022 wrote:

While the talent is great, I probably wouldn't keep him because of the low teamwork, consistency, AND intelligence.



yep... low intel, consistency and team work is bad no matter the talent... possibly a gunner if you did want to keep him lol (as thats a 'non' position in the current engine, and at least he could use the talent to get good BPOS lol)
Jinto
Posts: 3527
Posted on 2009-10-13 0:56:54
http://www.grid-iron.org/index.php?page=club&subpage=pldetails&team_id=3240&playerid=397433

What do you think of this QB pick up while i only paid 6k for him unlike my current guy...but what im wondering is if hes good to play now cause i NEED a backup QB cause if my current guy gets hurt i got a youth i just picked up with a passing of 1 so thats nothing really

Positioning 3 Tackling 1 Punting 5
Vision 1 Blocking 1 Speed 14
Intelligence 13 Passing 5 Strength 7
Footwork 1 Catching 1 Agility 3
Carrying 1 Kicking 5 Stamina 2

Cons 18

i might look for tranfers wrong but the way i see it anything is you can train anything but Int and Cons so find high there and avg for the spot your looking for
buddie625
Posts: 1940
Posted on 2009-10-13 1:04:08
Jinto wrote:

http://www.grid-iron.org/index.php?page=club&subpage=pldetails&team_id=3240&playerid=397433

What do you think of this QB pick up while i only paid 6k for him unlike my current guy...but what im wondering is if hes good to play now cause i NEED a backup QB cause if my current guy gets hurt i got a youth i just picked up with a passing of 1 so thats nothing really

Positioning 3 Tackling 1 Punting 5
Vision 1 Blocking 1 Speed 14
Intelligence 13 Passing 5 Strength 7
Footwork 1 Catching 1 Agility 3
Carrying 1 Kicking 5 Stamina 2

Cons 18

i might look for tranfers wrong but the way i see it anything is you can train anything but Int and Cons so find high there and avg for the spot your looking for



He looks ok, but I would be worried about the low footwork and Vision. It would also be nice to have a stronger QB. Another thing I would look at is his stamina. But this is just my opinion.
buckeye1022
Posts: 8799
Posted on 2009-10-13 1:15:28
I'd rather have higher vision, but like you said that can be trained. If you need him in a pinch he shouldn't kill you.
mdjseymour
Posts: 0
Posted on 2009-10-13 1:18:07
buddie625 wrote:

Jinto wrote:

http://www.grid-iron.org/index.php?page=club&subpage=pldetails&team_id=3240&playerid=397433

What do you think of this QB pick up while i only paid 6k for him unlike my current guy...but what im wondering is if hes good to play now cause i NEED a backup QB cause if my current guy gets hurt i got a youth i just picked up with a passing of 1 so thats nothing really

Positioning 3 Tackling 1 Punting 5
Vision 1 Blocking 1 Speed 14
Intelligence 13 Passing 5 Strength 7
Footwork 1 Catching 1 Agility 3
Carrying 1 Kicking 5 Stamina 2

Cons 18

i might look for tranfers wrong but the way i see it anything is you can train anything but Int and Cons so find high there and avg for the spot your looking for



He looks ok, but I would be worried about the low footwork and Vision. It would also be nice to have a stronger QB. Another thing I would look at is his stamina. But this is just my opinion.



agreed, personally i like QB's with a minimum of 18 Intelligence...

he is definatly a future prospect more than a 'ready to go' player...

my own backup is:

Positioning 3 Tackling 4 Punting 3
Vision 3 Blocking 4 Speed 15
Intelligence 18 Passing 5 Strength 9
Footwork 6 Catching 1 Agility 4
Carrying 5 Kicking 3 Stamina 3
OTHER
Teamwork 19 Consistency 19

although he sees very little play time... he is never likely to be anything but a backup...
Jinto
Posts: 3527
Posted on 2009-10-13 1:34:12
Thats all im looking for is someone to step in if my other guy get hurt but hes somewhat like my current QB when i picked him up except for he was ready to play then but warmed the bench for a while when i had an old man in there
 
Forum index >> Center for rookies >> Player Evaluations and Advice. Goto page : 1, 2, 3 ... 66, 67, 68 ... 75, 76, 77
Last posts