mdjseymour wrote: so... thoughts on this player.... 16yo, 4 talent, Positioning 4 Tackling 2 Punting 1 Vision 5 Blocking 4 Speed 11 Intelligence 2 Passing 4 Strength 11 Footwork 1 Catching 5 Agility 5 Carrying 3 Kicking 3 Stamina 3 Teamwork 3 Consistency 20

Personally, id give him to a team called Comeback Kid - the manager would really appreciate it

And he would probaby give him a go at WR

What should I do with these players?

First Player:

Talent 1

Positioning 1 Tackling 7 Punting 5
Vision 3 Blocking 7 Speed 13
Intelligence 2 Passing 3 Strength 10
Footwork 5 Catching 4 Agility 7
Carrying 7 Kicking 5 Stamina 2

Teamwork 8 Consistency 15

Natural Position: Gunner
Green Training Bars: Vision, Blocking, Speed

Second Player

Talent 3.5

Positioning 5 Tackling 7 Punting 5
Vision 5 Blocking 1 Speed 15
Intelligence 19 Passing 3 Strength 13
Footwork 6 Catching 3 Agility 6
Carrying 3 Kicking 6 Stamina 7

Teamwork 10 Consistency 7

Natural Position: Gunner
Green Training Bars: Strength, Agility
Light Green Training Bars: Passing

darkwingaa wrote: First Player: Talent 1 Positioning 1 Tackling 7 Punting 5 Vision 3 Blocking 7 Speed 13 Intelligence 2 Passing 3 Strength 10 Footwork 5 Catching 4 Agility 7 Carrying 7 Kicking 5 Stamina 2 Teamwork 8 Consistency 15

Low Talent means he can only reach BPOS of 3, and a skill of higher than 12 will take increasingly more work.. So probably a backup / only short term option no matter where he plays?

If speed and strength keep increasing the decent carrying and agility would suggest RB, but the low intelligence could be a hindrance.. alternatively, keep him as a gunner with his good tacking, agility, and footwork, it should be a fit, and bpos may not matter much until you find alternatives..

darkwingaa wrote: Second Player : Talent 3.5 Positioning 5 Tackling 7 Punting 5 Vision 5 Blocking 1 Speed 15 Intelligence 19 Passing 3 Strength 13 Footwork 6 Catching 3 Agility 6 Carrying 3 Kicking 6 Stamina 7 Teamwork 10 Consistency 7

Talent of 3.5 is a much better starting point, meaning BPOS can go up to 4.5

19 Intelligence is great, with good speed and strength, agility, footwork, tacking and vision all combine with intelligence to make me think.. LB, but consistency of 7 may concern you... personally i like a good amount of consistency, but, it has its positives as well as negatives, could still be a very good LB..


Anyway, just my opninin.. im sure others will have various views on it...

mdjseymour wrote: buckeye1022 wrote: 1 I would probably keep at gunner with his good tackling, good speed, and lack of talent. He could help elsewhere, but his upside is severely limited. 2 I would put at linebacker. dang it... after all my nice laying out etc you beat me to it... but at least we came to the same conclusion lol...

lol Well you know what they say. Great minds think alike.

Not sure what that has to do with me though.

Thanks for the quick responses. Ok, so I have to look for people with a high talent rating and hopefully high consistency. Sorry, still trying to absorb all this information. How about these players?

First Player:

Talent 4

Positioning 3 Tackling 7 Punting 3
Vision 6 Blocking 7 Speed 12
Intelligence 16 Passing 4 Strength 14
Footwork 3 Catching 1 Agility 1
Carrying 3 Kicking 7 Stamina 2

Teamwork 7 Consistency 20

Natural Position: Kick Returner

Second Player

Talent 4

Positioning 7 Tackling 2 Punting 3
Vision 2 Blocking 3 Speed 15
Intelligence 6 Passing 7 Strength 11
Footwork 7 Catching 5 Agility 5
Carrying 3 Kicking 6 Stamina 3

Teamwork 11 Consistency 15

Natural Position: Running Back
Green Training Bars: Footwork, Blocking, Catching, Str, Agility, Stamina

Third Player

Talent 3

Positioning 1 Tackling 7 Punting 7
Vision 2 Blocking 7 Speed 10
Intelligence 17 Passing 7 Strength 8
Footwork 6 Catching 7 Agility 5
Carrying 7 Kicking 2 Stamina 4

Teamwork 3 Consistency 13

Natural Position: Wide Receiver
Green Training Bars: Vision, Blocking, Catching, Agility