Hello, maybe it is just me that I am doing it wrong, but often times, with any orders, my team will punt the ball at for example at the 15 yard line even though my order says otherwise. I think there should be a more advanced fg order instead of "punt or kick a fg", so you can actually choose between fg or not

it's just like in real life.

It would probably be easy to incorporate quite a few things without fundamentally changing the game. As well as the things you've proposed, "hidden" skills that the game could use (e.g. some weighted combination of passing and strength to give a QB a "deep ball" attribute, speed and catching to give a WR a "deep threat", matching them up to create the QB/WR tandem with intelligence, along with the speed, catching, vision etc. of the CB determining how often he'd try to go deep. Similarly for the O-line, different weightings of strength and blocking, and perhaps footwork, to determine effectiveness in run and pass blocking). Of course this would require a new match engine but not necessarily a new user interface.

It would probably be easy to incorporate quite a few things without fundamentally changing the game. As well as the things you've proposed, "hidden" skills that the game could use (e.g. some weighted combination of passing and strength to give a QB a "deep ball" attribute, speed and catching to give a WR a "deep threat", matching them up to create the QB/WR tandem with intelligence, along with the speed, catching, vision etc. of the CB determining how often he'd try to go deep. Similarly for the O-line, different weightings of strength and blocking, and perhaps footwork, to determine effectiveness in run and pass blocking). Of course this would require a new match engine but not necessarily a new user interface.