TheFreakinStud wrote: buddie625 wrote: TheFreakinStud wrote: buddie625 wrote: Yeah, I am going to sit him until I see what his speed and strength are. Personally for me, his fitness skills already qualify him for a job at CB. Yeah, but if he capped at 16 in speed. I would be a very unhappy penguin Haha. 16 is fine to me. Most of the receivers they'll be going against have 12-16 speed. Most people don't take speed to seriously for WR, why should they for CB? Just my view.

have to agree... personally i wont take a WR with less than 16 speed (and if it is 16/17 it means h has to have 18+ intelligence to make up for it in my world). However my starting CB's are both 18+ intelligence, and 17+ speed (both still uncapped lol)

Old Mate wrote: Positioning 5 Tackling 4 Punting 5 Vision 6 Blocking 4 Speed 11 Intelligence 5 Passing 5 Strength 17 Footwork 1 Catching 6 Agility 2 Carrying 4 Kicking 4 Stamina 2 Talent 4, 18 years old Really unsure what to do with him but he seems pretty good all the same.

Dline or Oline with that strength and intelligence....

whats consistency like?

Just picked up a 16-year-old CB (Colton de Costa) from my Youth Pull ... with 5-star talent.

Positioning 5 Tackling 5 Punting 4
Vision 4 Blocking 3 Speed 14
Intelligence 2 Passing 3 Strength 14
Footwork 2 Catching 1 Agility 4
Carrying 5 Kicking 3 Stamina 4
OTHER
Teamwork 12 Consistency 11

Bare in mind, he's really, really dumb and has average consistency. Otherwise (talent especially), he's pretty good. What would you guys do with him? What are my options with such an uneven player? And how would you rate him: Did I find a jewel, a decent player, nothing special OR a flat-out dud?

Thanks,
Sean

Jinto wrote: DwyerSP wrote: Just picked up a 16-year-old CB (Colton de Costa) from my Youth Pull ... with 5-star talent. Positioning 5 Tackling 5 Punting 4 Vision 4 Blocking 3 Speed 14 Intelligence 2 Passing 3 Strength 14 Footwork 2 Catching 1 Agility 4 Carrying 5 Kicking 3 Stamina 4 OTHER Teamwork 12 Consistency 11 Bare in mind, he's really, really dumb and has average consistency. Otherwise (talent especially), he's pretty good. What would you guys do with him? What are my options with such an uneven player? And how would you rate him: Did I find a jewel, a decent player, nothing special OR a flat-out dud? Thanks, Sean Id call him nothing special cause the low INT kills his chances to play any skill spot and really leave him done to the Oline or Dline because a 5 Star talent cant over come being "Stupid"

Personally, i would say sell him, becasue someone will pay big for him... use the cash to build up your stadium etc...

or use him on special teams... no matter his Talent, he would have no place on my O or D with that intel (and yes i did release a 4.5 talent guy with intel that low....)

mdjseymour wrote: Do we think that... 4.5 Talent 10 Intel 18 T/W 18 Cons 17 Strength 17 Speed ...is a good start for a Tight End? Intel a little low?

Intelligence way too low. The rest is a little on the low side too.

I think anyone with a player like that should let me take them off their hands. They obviously will never be any good.